Manhattan Bagel Reviews
Manhattan Bagel has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 81 reviews. Customer feedback on Manhattan Bagel is mixed: Manhattan Bagel reviewers highlight positive aspects like fresh bagels, friendly service, variety of menu options, convenient locations, which strongly appeal to bagel lovers, busy professionals, families, breakfast enthusiasts. However, Manhattan Bagel is often criticized for its inconsistent quality, higher prices, limited seating, slow service during peak hours.
81 reviews
5 Stars
18
4 Stars
6
3 Stars
1
2 Stars
3
1 Star
0
How would you rate Manhattan Bagel?
All Manhattan Bagel Reviews (81)
john_Cimini76
May 23, 2026
"Cream cheese was the real winner"
I ordered from Manhattan Bagel mainly because I was craving bagels, but honestly... the cream cheese kind of ended up being the highlight. It tasted really fresh and had that nice thick texture, not watery or sad like you get at some places. I tried the veggie one too and it actually had a good amount of flavor. Only reason I’m going with 4 stars is because I do wish they put a little more on the bagel. Like, not a crazy amount, just a bit more. Still really good though, and yeah, I’d order again
0
Reply
barry-Lafollette
May 18, 2026
"The food tasted good, honestly. I liked the…"
The food tasted good, honestly. I liked the flavor, and the bagel itself was fine, but then I was kind of surprised by the size of the sandwich. For the price, I expected it to be a little more filling. Not bad at all, just left me wishing there was a bit more to it
0
Reply
andreahunter3858
April 08, 2026
"Not sure what happened today"
I don’t know if the coffee had been sitting too long or if it was just made weaker than usual, but it tasted kind of burnt and watery today. Definitely not what I was expecting...
0
Reply
SpencerSkiver
April 08, 2026
"Pretty Much on Time"
They showed up when they said they would, for the most part. I don’t expect everything to be perfect down to the minute, but basic common sense says being reasonably on time matters, and they were.
0
Reply
dixielambert0492
March 31, 2026
"My order was ready really fast, and I…"
My order was ready really fast, and I barely had to wait at all, which was a nice surprise. Happy with how smooth it went — that’s always a good sign, right?
0
Reply
JamesHines_95
March 30, 2026
"Quick and easy help"
I didn’t have to overthink it at all, I reached out, they jumped in fast, and the whole thing was handled before I knew it. Super easy experience...
0
Reply
janelle_Kelley01
March 28, 2026
"It showed up still warm and…"
It showed up still warm and soft, which was nice, but I’m not sure everything was quite up to the standard I expected. I’d appreciate some kind of compensation or credit for the inconvenience.
0
Reply
jane_Patterson84
March 26, 2026
"So... they got it right, and I’m…"
So... they got it right, and I’m really happy with how everything turned out.
0
Reply
LyndseyCannon_20
March 23, 2026
"Grabbed a breakfast sandwich and coffee from…"
Grabbed a breakfast sandwich and coffee from Manhattan Bagel, everything was actually hot when I got it. The bagel was warm, the egg and cheese were nicely melted, and the coffee wasn’t that sad lukewarm temperature you get at some places. I can’t say if it’s always like that or if I just caught them at a good time, but for this order, it made a big difference. Happy with it
0
Reply
chasealeshire7883
March 21, 2026
"Not gonna lie, the food was okay, but…"
Not gonna lie, the food was okay, but the wait kind of killed the experience for me. I ordered ahead thinking it would be ready, but I still ended up standing around for almost 25 minutes without much of an update. The staff did seem busy, so I get it, but it was still frustrating. I’m not sure I’d order from here again if I was in a rush.
0
Reply
RebeccaPage_51
March 20, 2026
"Not What I Expected"
I was confused because the website made it seem like everything would be fresh and made just right, but my sandwich didn’t really match that. The bread was soggy, and the turkey tasted kind of old. I was expecting something better based on what they show online.
0
Reply
hello_josephine078
March 14, 2026
"Great Office Breakfast!"
I ordered Manhattan Bagel for a small office breakfast, and it went so smoothly! The bagels were fresh, the spreads were packed neatly, and everything was ready right when I arrived. I’m always a little nervous about catering orders missing something, but everything was there and easy to set up. Everyone was happy, and I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
richard1990
March 09, 2026
"Really good bagels overall"
I grabbed a few bagels from Manhattan Bagel, and from what I remember, the flavor really stood out. The everything bagel had that good seasoning you want, and even the plain one had a fresh, slightly chewy texture that I usually look for in a bagel. I’m holding back one star only because one of them seemed a little dry by the time I got around to eating it, but it still tasted good. I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
james2004
February 01, 2026
"Fresh and Easy Breakfast"
Grabbed a bagel sandwich this morning and it really hit the spot. The veggies were crisp, the eggs tasted fresh, and nothing seemed like it had been sitting around. It was simple, tasty, and did exactly what I needed for breakfast. I’d definitely order it again soon
0
Reply
jacob.Lewis
January 31, 2026
"I’m always a little nervous with…"
I’m always a little nervous with stuff that’s this cheap because I feel like there has to be a catch, but i was pleasantly surprised. It was tasty, didn’t feel like I got fooled, and for the price it was totally worth it
0
Reply
Gloria-mavai
January 29, 2026
"Fair Prices for What You Get"
I grab food from Manhattan Bagel every now and then, and the prices seem fair. Like, it’s not dirt cheap or anything, but you get a decent amount of food, so it doesn’t feel like you’re getting ripped off. Roughly put, the portions match the price, and that’s good enough for me.
0
Reply
LouiseLacey
January 27, 2026
"Quick and Nice"
Staff was super nice. Fast too. No complaints.
0
Reply
CindyMildon
January 14, 2026
"Plenty to Pick From"
The menu actually has a ton of choices, so picking something for lunch has never been a problem for me. it’s kind of nice when a place makes that part easy for once.
0
Reply
WHITE
January 09, 2026
"Nice little stop before work"
I stopped in before work because I figured I deserved a decent coffee instead of rushing through my usual morning, and I’m glad I did. The place had a really nice vibe — clean, not too loud, and the staff kept the line moving without making it feel rushed. It was easy to sit for a bit and just enjoy my coffee before starting the day. I’d definitely come back...
0
Reply
DavidWendt_96
January 01, 2026
"I ordered bagels online from Manhattan…"
I ordered bagels online from Manhattan Bagel and it was one of those simple little wins where the website was easy to figure out, the pickup time was actually accurate, everything was packed up neatly, my whole order was right, and I was in and out without any hassle so yeah, nothing super dramatic to report, just a really smooth quick experience and I’d definitely do it again.
0
Reply
Have a question about Manhattan Bagel?
Log in to ask your Manhattan Bagel question!
Popular Brands
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
